BTC Magazine

Unlock All Stories, In depth,
exclusive & unfiltered

Subscribe

Subscribe
to our
newsletter

Explore Us

  • Home
  • Subscription
  • Collections
  • Podcast
  • Perks & Places
  • Authors
  • About
  • Partner With Us

View Categories

View All
  • Identity
  • Editorial
  • Health & Wellness
  • Travel Stories
  • Fashion and Lifestyle
  • Beauty Essentials
  • Canada Culture
  • Food and Culture

Readers

Subscribe

Partnerships

Partner with Us

Email

info@betweenthecoversmag.com

Support

Contact Us

Address

Toronto, Canada

© 2026 Between the Covers. All rights reserved.

PrivacyContactShop
ShopPerks & PlacesPodcasts
Between The Covers Magazine logo
Loading...
IdentityFood and CultureEditorial & VoicesCanada CultureFashion LifestyleBeautyTravel DestinationsHealth and Wellness
HomeCollectionsMakeup TrendsLuxury Makeup BrandsPapa Beauty Mascara Blush and Lip Liner Choosing Who You Feel Like Tonight

Papa Beauty: Mascara, Blush, and Lip Liner You're Not Choosing a Colour — You're Choosing Who You Feel Like Tonight

ByJessica Spagnuolo·Updated August 10, 2026
Share:
PAPA beauty products
0comments7views

Key takeaways

  • Makeup isn't about expectation, it's about mood. The writer only reaches for the bag on nights she's already happy, not to meet anyone else's standard.

  • Minimalism can feel more intentional than a full routine. A single coat of mascara is often enough to make the face in the mirror feel "more itself," not decorated.

  • Application technique matters as much as the product. Using fingers instead of a brush for liquid blush helps color set into skin for a more natural, lived-in look.

  • Naming and identity are part of the beauty ritual. A lip liner shade's name (like Power Trip or Juliet) can shape how someone feels going into the night, not just how they look.

  • The finishing step is about cohesion, not concealment. Setting spray and a stipple brush blend everything into "one thing," making the makeup feel meant rather than sealed on.

You're Not Choosing a Colour — You're Choosing Who You Feel Like Tonight

On the difference between wearing makeup and choosing it


The bag sits on my dresser and most days, I walk past it.

Not every day is a makeup day. Not most, actually. I go to school, I go to work, I run my errands, and I do it all in just my face — the same one I went to sleep in the night before, the same one anyone who knows me has seen a thousand times.

The days the makeup bag opens are quieter, somehow. The nights I'm meeting my friends, or my family, or sitting across from the person I love at a restaurant we chose together. Nobody's expecting anything different from me. That's the part I didn't understand for a long time — I don't do it for the expectation. I do it on the nights I'm already happy.

The bag is small. What I reach for inside isn’t.

The Case for Just Mascara

The first coat always surprises me a little.

Not because of how different it looks — it doesn't, really, not dramatically. But there's something about the eyes in the mirror after one pass of the wand that makes them feel more present.

Mascara was the first thing I ever wore, and on most nights it's still the only thing. Not because I don't have other options — the bag has more in it — but because it tends to be enough. A single coat along the top lashes, maybe a touch on the bottom, and the face in the mirror is mine in a way that feels intentional. Not decorated. Just more itself.

The PAPA Mascara is water-resistant and lengthening, with Vitamin E in the formula to condition as it coats — which, for someone who doesn't wear it every day, matters more than it might seem. Infrequent wear can dry lashes out. The Vitamin E keeps them from paying the price of the occasions.

One coat. The rest is already in your eyes.

Liquid Blush That Looks Like Your Skin Did It

I put blush on with my fingers.

Not because I'm supposed to — I'm not sure I am — but because the warmth of your hands helps the colour set into your skin in a way that a brush doesn't. It goes on quickly, blends before you overthink it, and by the time you step back from the mirror, you look like you've been somewhere. Not like you applied something. Like your face just did that.

That's what I want from blush. Not drama — just the colour your cheeks would be anyway, on a night where everything is right. A little flush, a little warmth, the kind that reads as good health or a good mood or both. Liquid blush gets closer to that than anything powdered because the formula sits in the skin rather than on top of it. Buildable if you want more, sheerer if you don't, and dewy in a way that catches light without trying. The PAPA Liquid Blush is exactly this — a soft, flushed warmth that looks like the night is already going well.

Your fingers put it on. Your face was already wearing it.

Why Your Lip Liner's Name Is Half the Decision

The lip is where it gets specific.

Everything else — the mascara, the blush — you can adjust in your mind before you apply it. You know roughly what you're getting. But a lip liner has a name, and the name tends to make the decision for you. Power Trip. Juliet. Scarlet. Beach Babe. You're not choosing a colour. You're choosing who you feel like tonight. That's an entirely different thing.

I like that by the time I'm at the lip, I've already been asked a question I didn't know I was answering.

The PAPA Automatic Lip Liner — Power Trip, or Juliet, or Scarlet, or Beach Babe — goes on first, defining the shape before the rest follows. Retractable, so there's no sharpening, no ceremony, just the colour you chose. The PAPA Lip Plumper goes over — cayenne and ginger in the formula, which means you'll feel it working, a slight warmth along the edges that turns into something fuller within minutes. It's one of the more honest products I know of. It tells you exactly what it's doing.

Together they're less of a two-step and more of a single decision with a very satisfying follow-through.

The name of the shade told you who you’d be tonight, the plumper made sure she showed up.

The Setting Spray Step I Do Differently

I spray first, then fan, then brush.

Not because I read it somewhere — because I found that the setting spray settles better when you give it a moment before working it in. The mist goes on close enough to land evenly, and then I fan my face with my hand for a few seconds. Letting it sit. Letting it decide where it wants to be. Then the brush — not sweeping, just pressing — works the spray gently into everything underneath.

It melds. That's the only word for what happens. The mascara, the blush, the liner — by the time the brush lifts off, it reads as one thing. Not several products sitting on a face. Just a face.

The PAPA Stipple & Blend Foundation Brush is built for exactly this: soft enough to press without disturbing, precise enough to reach everything. The PAPA Setting Spray goes on first, and the brush follows. Together they're the step that tells everything to stay.

Not because you sealed it. Because you meant it.

Already Ready

By the time I sit down at the table, I've already forgotten about the bag.

Not because the makeup isn't there — it is, it's doing what it was supposed to — but because by the time I walk through the door, it's stopped being makeup. The mascara, the blush, the liner — they've settled into the night the same way I have.

The bag isn't for getting ready. It's for already being ready, and wanting to mark it somehow. Wanting the outside to say what the inside already knows — that tonight is one of the good ones.

The bag is on the dresser, and I am at the table — laughing too hard, staying too late, and leaving thinking I should do this more often.

There's more to "Papa Beauty Mascara Blush and Lip Liner Choosing Who You Feel Like Tonight" just below — the turning point, the details, and what comes next.

Subscribers read every word, the moment they join, plus every issue of Between the Covers.

No skimmed previews — the full story and everything else that comes with membership.

Members only from here

Keep reading with a membership

You've reached the preview. Subscribe for the full article — plus every issue and subscriber perks.

7-day free trial, then from $3.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Become a subscriberSign in

Instant access · Cancel anytime

  • Unlimited premium articles
  • Digital magazine access
  • Subscriber perks & places
★★★★★

“I started reading for the fashion pieces, but the essays are what kept me coming back.”

Maya R. · Toronto reader

Frequently asked questions

The writer doesn't wear makeup out of obligation or expectation, but on nights she's already feeling good, meeting friends, family, or someone she loves. It becomes a way of marking a happy occasion rather than a daily requirement or performance for others.

A single coat of mascara can make eyes feel more present without looking dramatically different. For infrequent wearers, a formula with Vitamin E helps condition lashes so occasional use doesn't dry them out, keeping the look natural rather than heavy.

Finger application uses hand warmth to help color set into skin naturally, creating a lived-in flush rather than a visibly applied one. Liquid formulas sit in the skin rather than on top of it, giving a dewy, buildable finish that reads as healthy.

A lip liner's name, like Power Trip or Scarlet, often shapes the mood someone brings into an evening, turning color choice into an emotional decision. Paired with a lip plumper containing cayenne and ginger, the routine becomes a single confident step.

Setting spray blends mascara, blush, and liner into one cohesive look rather than separate products sitting on the face. Applying it before brushing, then pressing it in gently, helps everything meld together so the makeup feels intentional, not just sealed on.

Keep exploring

Membership

Stories worth finishing

Unlimited articles, digital issues, and exclusive perks. Built for Canadian women who want more than a scroll.

  • Unlimited premium articles
  • Digital magazine access
  • Subscriber perks & places
Become a subscriber

7-day free trial · From $3.99/mo

Already a member? Sign in

You are reading in

Beauty

Makeup Trends · Luxury Makeup Brands

Explore pillar

Trending stories

See all
  1. 01
    Woman's Case for Choosing Solo Travel in Midlife

    Do not Wait to Be Chosen: Womans Case for Choosing Solo Travel in Midlife

    Travel

  2. 02
    tracy-moore

    I Abandoned Myself A Lot

    Spotlight

  3. 03
    Nighttime Skincare Ritual steps Nobody Gets to Watch This Skincare Routine

    Nighttime Skincare Ritual: Four Steps Your Skin Takes When Nobody Is Watching

    Skincare Routine for Women

  4. 04
    Woman lying in bed staring at ceiling

    What My Gut Knew — Learning To Read Your Nervous System Before It Screams

    Nutrition for women

Explore pillars

  • Identity
  • Food and Culture
  • Editorial & Voices
  • Canada Culture
  • Fashion Lifestyle
  • Beauty
  • Travel Destinations
  • Health and Wellness

More in Makeup Trends

  • New Beauty Launches

In Beauty

  • Skincare Routine for Women

Explore pillars

  • Identity
  • Food and Culture
  • Editorial & Voices
  • Canada Culture
  • Fashion Lifestyle
  • Travel Destinations
  • Health and Wellness
  • Collections
  • Authors
  • Podcasts

Read the full story

7-day free trial · From $3.99/mo

Subscribe

Comments

No comments yet

No comments to show yet. Subscribe to join the conversation.

Subscribe to comment on this article.

← More Beauty articles

Related Articles

Become a Skincare Ambassador
  • 300likes
  • 90comments
  • 210Kviews

Makeup Trends/New Beauty Launches

Join Skincare Ambassador Program Do not Need Followers Count

By JEO Publishing

Explore Our Curated Collection

Thoughtfully designed products for the discerning reader

Bookshelf Essentials

Curated book accessories for the discerning reader

Exclusive Merchandise

Thoughtfully designed products for book lovers

Perfect Gifts

Unique items for the bibliophile in your life

Visit Our Shop

BETWEEN

Subscribe for Full Access

Explore our latest stories, get full access, and keep reading deeper — premium articles, podcasts, and member perks in one subscription.

7-day free trial, then from $3.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

THE COVERS